Conversation 5.1. Participation and the Troubles with Intelligence

Discussion of Full Papers from Full Paper Session 5 and Exploratory Papers (listed below). In this 19th edition of the PDC, Full and Exploratory papers will be organized into Conversations, that is, experimental formats of presentation and discussion of the papers based on triggering questions and authors’ interactions. 

Full Papers:

• 1149: Hizca, a Critical Video Game and Indigenous Co-creation.
  Authors: Torres-Parra, Carlos Roberto; Tobón-Giraldo, Isabel Cristina; Ortegón-Pérez, Germán.
• 1156: Frames of Participation: Design as Enquiry in Exploring Technological Futures of Emergency Care.
  Authors: Ambe, Aloha May; Salisbury, Isaac; Grundgeiger, Tobias; Bodner, Daniel; Rothwell, Sean; Brown, Nathan; Matthews, Ben.
  
• 1158: Dreaming with MAKOTO: Co-Designing an “Older Adult” Voice Assistant Intervention for Implicit Ageism.
  Authors: Seaborn, Katie; Watanabe, Mizuki; Fabre, Émilie; Riesch, Paul; Nam, Somang; Mandai, Yuto; Kojima, Miu.
  
• 1160: Theatre of the Tech-Oppressed: Exploring Algorithmic Injustice Through Participatory Performances.
  Authors: Babai, Najme; Durall, Eva; Iivari, Netta; Kinnula, Marianne; Sejer Iversen, Ole.
  
• 1239: Designing Responsible AI with Indigenous Communities: Towards Participatory AI with ovaHimba and San People in Namibia.
  Authors: Indongo, Naftali Ndeapo; Smith, Rachel Charlotte; Kandjengo, Shorty; Mbinge, Uariaike; Winschiers-Theophilus, Heike.

Exploratory Papers:

• 259: Designing for Co-Existence: Exploring AI as a More-Than-Human Actor in Participatory Design.
  Author: Sourati, Maryam; Croon, Anna.
  
• 1351: Reclaiming Participation through Daoist Cosmology: Patterns of the Unseen in Human-AI Co-creation.
  Authors: Liu, Yicen; Wang, Lu; Kang, Lijuan.
  
• 1578: InterSea: Designing an Archive of Socio-ecological Relationships in the Mediterranean Basin.
  Authors: Mattei, Michela; Sollazzo, Flavia.
  

The discussion will be guided by the following questions prepared by the Chairs: 

• Q1: Whose intelligences are recognized, and whose remain unintelligible?​
• Q2: What does it mean to design with multiple intelligences under conditions of partial knowledge?​
• Q3: What are the costs of mobilizing intelligence through participation?